Interesting mate... I say that because I was massively disappointed by the Focus RS, hence it would be towards the bottom of the list for me. Obviously, it's a very personal/subjective thing but my then partner and I walked away disappointed, went over the road to the Honda dealer, and bought a brand new EP3 Type-R (after a test drive). We both loved the Type-R.
Talking of Type-Rs, the DC2 would probably be towards the top of the list with the Trophy for me. Again, talking of Type-Rs, I get loads of stick for not particularly liking the original EK9 Civic Type-R. Honestly, I didn't get what all the fuss was about - despite being somewhat of a Honda/Type-R fan. I just didn't get the enjoyment and excitement I felt in the likes of the Trophy (or other sorted hatches).
I'm basing this on driving my brothers EK9 way back in the mid 2000's so my memories might not be 100% correct
I loved driving it at the time.
It was the sort of car that never seemed playful or would cock a wheel or start stepping out on you,it always seemed very much a track biased setup.As in it wasn't really interested in being playful,unlike something like a Trophy or even it's more illustrious brother,the DC2 Integra which could and would step out on you if you provoked it enough or you were really pushing it.
I still remember driving the EK9 and the faster you went into a turn the more it just stuck to its line,often the harder you drove it the more it would just go where you pointed it,no understeer.
For pure driving thrills the DC2 would still have the upper hand on it.
But the combination of the handling combined with that screaming B16 all while sitting in those brilliant Recaro's left an impression on me.