Id buy the cheapest one. Or the one with the RS2.
But i buy on mechanical condition & ability to take abuse on track, not whether i can make it look pretty with 15 layers of polish.
Gutted for you!! Just cancel the claim & fix it yourself, really doesnt look that bad at all!!
Remember the garage will need to use brand new parts from Renault, which bump the price up, you wont have to ...
If you've gone through the insurance they will write that off lol.
Just buy another 1*2 for a grand, swop the bits over and flog the rest.
Will end up costing you nothing after you make profit selling all the other bits off!!
Now on ebay: http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/2005-55-RENAULT-CLIO-RENAULT-SPORT-TROPHY-182-BUILD-NUMBER-351-DAMAGED-/350744624158?pt=Automobiles_UK&hash=item51aa023c1e
Minimal damage by the looks of things!